Free-99? Think Again — Your Employer’s Gift Ain't Tax-Free
Your fancy holiday “thank you” gift might come with a tax bill
It’s that time of year again.
Your employer hands you some random “holiday appreciation” gift.
A cheap plastic mug you’ll never use.
A fleece vest that fits two sizes too big.
This year, they splurge and hand you a $200 Theragun that you’ll never touch.
But who cares? It’s free 99, right?
And here’s the part nobody expects:
If you toss that gift in the trash, or let it rot in your trunk, you might actually be losing money. Real money.
Because the IRS has very strong opinions about your corporate swag, especially the fancy stuff.
Free-99? The IRS Doesn’t Think So
Unfortunately, your “free” gift might not be free-99.
At least the tax code says so.
To qualify as a true, tax-free gift, it must come from “detached, disinterested generosity […] love, respect, admiration, charity”.
That exact language comes from a 1960 Supreme Court case: Duberstein v. Commissioner.
Your employer did not give you that vibrating massage machine out of admiration of your clinical brilliance.
They gave it because you work for them.
And that changes everything.
Section 102(c): The Grinch of Employer Gifts
The IRS/Congress saw this problem coming decades ago.
So they created a special rule.
Internal Revenue Code §102(c) says that when an employer gives an employee something of value to an employee, it is not a gift. It is a compensation!
And It’s that time of year again.
Your employer hands you some random “holiday appreciation” gift.
A cheap plastic mug you’ll never use.
A fleece vest that fits two sizes too big.
This year, they splurge and hand you a $200 Theragun that you’ll never touch.
But who cares? It’s free 99, right?
And here’s the part nobody expects:
If you toss that gift in the trash, or let it rot in your trunk, you might actually be losing money. Real money.
Because the IRS has very strong opinions about your corporate swag, especially the fancy stuff.
Free-99? The IRS Doesn’t Think So
Unfortunately, your “free” gift might not be free-99.
At least the tax code says so.
To qualify as a true, tax-free gift, it must come from “detached, disinterested generosity […] love, respect, admiration, charity”.
That exact language comes from a 1960 Supreme Court case: Duberstein v. Commissioner.
Your employer did not give you that vibrating massage machine out of admiration of your clinical brilliance.
They gave it because you work for them.
And that changes everything.
Section 102(c): The Grinch of Employer Gifts
The IRS/Congress saw this problem coming decades ago.
So they created a special rule.
Internal Revenue Code §102(c) says that when an employer gives an employee something of value to an employee, it is not a gift. It is a compensation.
And compensation is taxed as part of your gross income!
Translation:
If your boss gives you something valuable, the IRS is already counting it as taxable income whether you keep it or not.
The Few Exceptions
There are only two meaningful escape hatches:
#1: De minimis fringe benefits
Tiny stuff from Temu that’s annoying to track, like a a $5 mug.
But, not a $200 TheraGun.
#2: Employee achievement awards
Think trophies or a small token for 10 years of service.
Anything beyond that?
Taxable!
The Practical Lesson
If your corporate holiday gift - especially a fancy one like Theragun - is useless to you, put it on Facebook Marketplace and at least get your money back.
Why?
Because the IRS already decided you’re paying tax on it.
Or, if it’s actually something you like, you might as well enjoy it, because you’re paying for it anyway (although at a discount).
And that, my doctor friends, is how holiday cheer becomes taxable compensation in America.
Disclaimer: click here
Thanks for reading Tax Clinic for Doctors ! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.